You need a sparky. A plumber. Maybe a lime-plasterer for that Victorian terrace. You open your laptop and three big names stare back. Checkatrade. MyBuilder. Rated People. They all promise "verified" pros. They all claim thousands of reviews. But the devil lives in the detail – specifically in the lead fees tradespeople pay, the insurance minimums they enforce, and how they handle disputes when a job goes sideways. At HireAnything we've audited the lot. Here's the unvarnished breakdown for 2026.
Why the Platform You Choose Matters in 2026
The Shift from Directory to Marketplace
Five years ago these sites were glorified Yellow Pages. Today they're lead-generation engines. Tradespeople pay per quote – typically £15 to £35 per lead on MyBuilder, £20 to £40 on Rated People, while Checkatrade runs a subscription model (£30–£60/month) plus optional lead boosts. That cost gets baked into your quote. A £2,500 bathroom refit might carry £150–£300 in platform overheads you never see.
What Homeowners Actually Pay
Expect day rates of £200–£350 for a time-served electrician, £180–£300 for a plumber, £250–£450 for a heritage carpenter. Platform fees don't change those baselines much, but they do affect which tradespeople bother to quote. High-fee platforms push out the best one-man bands. They simply don't need the aggro.
The Big Three: Head-to-Head Comparison
Checkatrade – The Established Heavyweight
Still the default for many. Their vetting includes ID checks, £2M public liability minimums (many carry £5M), and trade association memberships. The subscription model means pros aren't penalised per quote – they quote freely. Downside: the review system is heavily gamed. We've seen firms with 500+ reviews and a 9.8 score that subcontract everything to unvetted labour. Always ask "who's actually turning up on Monday?"
MyBuilder – The Quote-First Challenger
You post a job. Tradespeople pay to quote. You get 3–5 responses inside 24 hours. Great for speed. Bad for depth. Verification is lighter – basic ID and insurance upload, no mandatory trade body membership. Their "MyBuilder Guarantee" covers deposits up to £1,000 if a trader vanishes, but only if you pay through their platform (they take 2.5% + 20p). Most decent pros refuse that fee. You'll often get the keen, not the best.
Rated People – The Volume Player
Similar pay-per-lead model. They claim 50,000+ trades. Their "Quality Score" algorithm weights response speed and quote volume – which rewards desk-jockey firms over craftsmen on site. Homeowner protection: a mediation service, not insurance. If a roofer botches your lead valley, you're negotiating, not claiming. Use for standard jobs – boiler swaps, fence panels – not complex heritage work.
Quick Comparison Table
| Platform | Trader Cost Model | Min Insurance | Verification Depth | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Checkatrade | Subscription (£30–£60/mo) | £2M PL (£5M common) | ID + Trade Body + Referees | General repairs, extensions |
| MyBuilder | Pay-per-lead (£15–£35) | £1M PL | ID + Insurance upload | Quick quotes, standard installs |
| Rated People | Pay-per-lead (£20–£40) | £1M PL | ID + Algorithm score | Volume jobs, multiple quotes |
Beyond the Big Three: Niche Platforms for Specialist Work
Heritage & Conservation Specialists
If you own a listed building, the big three are nearly useless. Look at The Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB) contractor list, Historic England's Heritage Register, or Heritage Builder (a niche platform launching late 2025). These pros carry £5M PL insurance and professional indemnity. Day rates £350–£600. Book 6–8 weeks out. They don't pay for leads. You find them via conservation officers or word of mouth.
Green Retrofit & Heat Pump Installers
MCS certification is non-negotiable for heat pumps. Check Microgeneration Certification Scheme (MCS) installer search or TrustMark (government-endorsed). Platform fees here are zero – the certification is the filter. Expect £3,500–£7,000 for an air-source heat pump install including cylinder. VAT at 5% on energy-saving materials.
Verification, Insurance & Your Legal Safety Net
Public Liability & The £5M Benchmark
Standard domestic PL is £2M. For anything structural – roof work, basement digs, load-bearing wall removal – demand £5M. Ask for the certificate. Check the expiry date. Photograph it. If a platform says "we verify insurance", ask for their audit process. Most do a once-a-year upload. A policy can be cancelled Tuesday; the platform knows Friday.
Consumer Rights Act 2015 in Practice
Services must be performed with "reasonable care and skill". Materials must be "fit for purpose". If a platform-mediated job fails, your contract is with the trader, not the platform. The platform's terms usually disclaim liability. Your leverage: a Letter Before Action citing CRA 2015, sent recorded delivery. 80% settle before court. Keep a paper trail – WhatsApp screenshots, emailed specs, dated photos.
Pro Tips for Booking Through Any Platform
- Never pay a deposit >10% before materials arrive on site. Use a credit card for Section 75 protection (£100–£30,000).
- Demand a written schedule of works with milestones and stage payments. "Phase 1: strip out – £800. Phase 2: first fix – £1,200."
- Check the trader's Companies House filing history. A dissolved company reincarnated as "Smith & Son Builders Ltd" last month? Walk away.
- Book 3–6 weeks ahead for peak season (April–October). The best pros are booked solid. HireAnything suppliers confirm: last-minute bookings attract the available, not the able.
A badge on a profile means the platform checked a document on a Tuesday. It doesn't mean they watched the work on Wednesday. Treat verification as a baseline filter, not a quality guarantee.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform offers the strongest homeowner protection if a trader disappears with my deposit?
MyBuilder's guarantee covers up to £1,000 if you pay via their platform (they take 2.5% + 20p). Checkatrade and Rated People offer mediation only. Your best protection: pay deposits by credit card (Section 75) and stage payments only for completed milestones.
Are Checkatrade reviews reliable for spotting cowboys?
Not entirely. Firms can solicit reviews from friends, suppress negative ones via private resolution, or subcontract to unvetted teams. Cross-reference: search the trader's name + "County Court Judgment" or "Trading Standards". Check Companies House for strike-off notices.
How do I find a lime-plasterer for a Grade II listed cottage?
Don't use the big three. Contact your local conservation officer (council planning dept) for approved contractors. Search the SPAB contractor list or Heritage Builder (launching 2025). Expect £350–£600/day. Book 8 weeks out. Verify £5M PL + professional indemnity.
What's the typical lead fee a tradesperson pays on MyBuilder or Rated People?
MyBuilder: £15–£35 per quote. Rated People: £20–£40. A plumber quoting on five jobs spends £100–£200 before winning one. That cost lands in your final invoice. Checkatrade's subscription model avoids per-quote fees, so you'll often get keener pricing from established firms there.