You need a plumber. Yesterday. The boiler's making a noise like a dying whale. You open your phone. Three apps stare back. Checkatrade. Rated People. MyBuilder. They all promise "verified" pros. They all claim "peace of mind". But the devil hides in the lead fees, the vetting depth, and the small print on your £5M Public Liability cover. At HireAnything we've audited the lot. This is what we found.
Why 2026 Changes The Game For Homeowners
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 got teeth. HSE enforcement on domestic gas and electric work tightened. PIPA tagging on portable appliances is now standard audit fodder. Platforms that used to be glorified directories now have to prove ongoing compliance, not just a one-off badge. Booking 3 to 6 weeks ahead isn't just polite. It's the only way to guarantee a Gas Safe engineer who carries current PIPA records and a valid £5M Public Liability cert. Miss that window and you're rolling dice.
The Big Three: Head-to-Head
Checkatrade: The Subscription Heavyweight
Checkatrade charges trades a monthly sub. Roughly £45–£65/month depending on trade category. No per-lead fee. That sounds clean. But it creates a volume incentive. Busy plumbers stay. Quiet ones quit. You get a deep pool. Vetting includes ID, address, insurance certs, and a sample of customer refs checked by phone. They display the Checkatrade Standard badge. It means the firm has £2M Public Liability minimum. Many carry £5M. Homeowner protection? A dispute resolution service. It's not binding arbitration. It's mediation. Works if both sides play nice. Fails if the roofer ghosts you.
Pro Tip: Filter by "Checkatrade Standard" AND "£5M PL Insurance" in the app. Takes 10 seconds. Saves weeks of grief.
Rated People: The Lead-Fee Marketplace
Rated People runs on pay-per-lead. Trades buy credits. A bathroom refit lead might cost £18–£35. A boiler swap £12–£25. You post a job. Up to three trades get your details. They pay to contact you. Vetting is lighter. ID check. Insurance upload. No mandatory phone refs. The platform takes a slice. Homeowner protection? A "Quality Guarantee" up to £1,000 if the trade vanishes mid-job. Conditions apply. You must pay via the platform. Cash jobs void it. App usability is slick. Push notifications when a trade views your job. Good for speed. Risky for complex builds.
MyBuilder: The Hybrid Model
MyBuilder blends sub and lead fees. Trades pay ~£30/month plus* reduced lead costs. Vetting sits between the other two. ID, insurance, and a portfolio review. They push "Verified" badges hard. Homeowner protection includes a "Deposit Protection" scheme. You pay deposit to MyBuilder. Released in stages. Solid for projects over £2k. App feels dated. Clunky photo upload. But the deposit escrow is a genuine differentiator. Use it for extensions. Skip it for a leaky tap.
Vetting Process Comparison: What Actually Gets Checked
- Identity: All three verify photo ID and address. Checkatrade does a soft credit search on the business. Others don't.
- Insurance: Checkatrade demands sight of current cert. Rated People and MyBuilder accept uploads. None auto-verify expiry dates monthly.
- Competence: Gas Safe / NICEIC / OFTEC numbers are displayed if provided. None cross-check live registers in real time. You must click the link yourself.
- References: Checkatrade phones 2–3 past clients. Rated People relies on platform reviews. MyBuilder asks for a portfolio.
Bottom line: You are the final vetting layer. Ask for the Gas Safe card. Photograph it. Check the expiry on the HSE website. Takes 60 seconds.
Cost Breakdown: Who Pays What
| Platform | Homeowner Cost | Trade Cost (Typical) | Hidden Gotchas |
|---|---|---|---|
| Checkatrade | Free | £45–£65/month sub | Trades may inflate quotes to cover sub |
| Rated People | Free (if not using escrow) | £12–£35 per lead | Lead sold to 3 trades; you get 3 calls at 7am |
| MyBuilder | Free (escrow optional) | £30/month + £5–£15/lead | Escrow fee 1.5% + VAT on project value |
Typical day rates you'll see quoted via any platform in 2026: Plumber £220–£350/day. Electrician £200–£320/day. Carpenter £190–£300/day. London and Southeast add 20–30%. Always ask for a fixed price on defined scope. Day rates invite scope creep.
App Usability & Real-World Experience
Checkatrade's app is functional. Search, filter, message. Review feed is chronological. No AI summaries. Rated People wins on UX. Clean dashboard. Job timeline. Instant chat. MyBuilder feels like 2015. Slow. Buggy image upload. But the deposit escrow workflow works. If you're managing a £15k loft conversion, MyBuilder's escrow beats a WhatsApp promise. If you need a tap washer changed Tuesday, Rated People's speed wins.
Pro Tips For Party Planners & Event Hosts
- Need a temporary kitchen for a wedding marquee? Search "catering equipment install" on Checkatrade. Filter "£5M PL". Book 6 weeks out.
- Outdoor lighting for a summer party? Rated People. Post Friday 10am. Electricians quote by lunch. Check NICEIC number before they climb the ladder.
- Structural beam for a knock-through? MyBuilder escrow. Stage payments: design, steel delivery, install, sign-off. Protects your deposit.
- Always screenshot the trade's insurance cert and Gas Safe card. Save to cloud. If HSE asks, you have proof of due diligence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform offers the strongest homeowner protection?
MyBuilder's deposit escrow is the only legally segregated fund. Checkatrade's mediation is voluntary. Rated People's £1k guarantee requires platform payment. For jobs over £3k, escrow wins.
Can I avoid platform fees by contacting trades directly?
Yes. Most trades list phone numbers on profiles. But you lose the platform's insurance verification snapshot, review history, and any dispute leverage. Save £0. Risk £thousands.
How do I verify a trade's Gas Safe registration in real time?
Open the Gas Safe Register website. Enter the 7-digit licence number from their card. Check expiry and qualified work categories. Do this before they touch your boiler.
What if the work fails Building Control sign-off?
Platform dispute schemes don't cover Building Regs failures. Your contract with the trade must specify "compliance with Building Regulations". Use a JCT Minor Works contract for anything structural. Platforms won't provide it.
Final Verdict: Match The Tool To The Job
Small repair, speed matters? Rated People. Medium project, want vetted pool? Checkatrade. Large project, need money protection? MyBuilder escrow. Or skip the app lottery entirely. At HireAnything we connect you directly with verified Tradesperson Hire providers who carry current £5M PL, Gas Safe, NICEIC, and PIPA compliance. Transparent quotes. No lead fees. No middleman markup. Book 3 to 6 weeks ahead for peak seasonal certainty.